Differences Between Slat Conveyors and Belt Conveyors: Slat Conveyors Are Preferred for Rigid Materials and Harsh Working Conditions
Author :
Slat conveyors and belt conveyors are both types of continuous conveying equipment, widely used in industries such as mining, chemical, food, and logistics. However, there are significant differences between them in terms of structural design, working principles, and application scenarios. The following is a detailed comparative analysis from seven key aspects:
Ⅰ. Comparison of Core Structure and Working Principle
Comparison | Slat conveyor | Belt Conveyor |
Load-bearing Components | Made of metal (steel slat, stainless steel slat) or plastic “slats” (such as link slats, apron slats), the slats are connected by chains/ track to form a continuous “slat conveyor belt” | Made of flexible materials such as rubber, canvas, PVC, nylon, etc., the "belt” (conveyor belt) is tensioned at both ends by drums to form a loop. |
Drive Method | The motor drives the chain (or sprocket), which moves the slats along the track in a cyclical motion, and the material is carried along with the slats. | The motor drives the drive drum, which moves the belt in a cyclical motion through the friction between the drum and the belt, and the material moves synchronously with the belt. |
Support Structure | The slats are supported by fixed tracks or idlers below, with a strong rigid structure capable of withstanding significant impact. | The belt is supported by idlers (flat idlers, troughed idlers) below, with the idler spacing designed according to the belt width and material weight, and an overall flexible structure. |
Ⅱ. Key Performance Differences
1.Material Adaptability: “Rigid Load-bearing” vs "Flexible Load-bearing”
Slat conveyor:
• Due to the rigid slats used as load-bearing components, it is suitable for conveying large, heavy, sharp, high-temperature, or corrosive materials, such as ores, coke, steel slag, high-temperature castings, and acid-base chemical raw materials.
• The slats can be designed as "sealed” (to prevent material leakage) or "perforated” (for draining or cooling), and the material will not slide due to excessive incline angles.
Belt Conveyor:
• Because the belt is made of flexible material, it is more suitable for conveying bulk, granular, powdery, or lightweight block materials, such as coal, grain, cement, fertilizer, and packages.
• It is necessary to avoid conveying sharp materials (which can easily puncture the belt), high-temperature materials (above 80℃ can age the belt), or highly corrosive materials (which can corrode the belt surface).
2.Conveying Angle: "Steep Conveying” vs "Gentle Conveying”
Slat conveyor:
• The rigid slats provide sufficient friction and support, allowing for steep incline conveying (maximum incline angle can reach 30°-45°, and some "high-angle slat conveyors” are nearly vertical), with minimal risk of material rolling down.
• Some models (such as scraper conveyors) can achieve combined horizontal+incline+vertical conveying, offering strong spatial adaptability.
Belt Conveyor:
• Depending on the friction between the belt and the material, the conventional incline angle is relatively small (maximum 18°for flat belts, maximum 25°for troughed belts);for high-angle conveying, a "wave barrier belt” (maximum 60°) is required, but this makes the structure more complex and increases costs.
• Excessive incline angles can cause material "slippage” or "spillage,” making it more suitable for gentle conveying.
3.Operational Stability and Maintenance Costs
Slat conveyor:
• Advantages:The rigid structure is highly resistant to impact, with tight cooperation between the slats and the track, making it less likely to deviate and resulting in a long service life (metal slats can last 5-10 years).
• Disadvantages:Moving parts (chains, sprockets) require regular lubrication, increasing maintenance frequency;material leakage may occur at slat joints (sealing devices are needed), the equipment is heavy, and energy consumption is slightly higher.
Belt Conveyor:
• Advantages:The flexible belt operates smoothly and quietly, with no complex transmission components, making maintenance simple (only regular checks of belt tension and idler wear are needed);good material sealing (troughed belts can reduce spillage), lightweight equipment, and low energy consumption.
• Disadvantages:The belt is prone to wear and deviation (alignment devices are needed), and if punctured by sharp materials, the entire belt needs to be replaced, resulting in a shorter service life (about 2-3 years for ordinary rubber belts);high requirements for material purity (metal impurities can damage the belt).
4.Temperature and Environmental Adaptability
Slat conveyor:
• Metal slats can withstand high temperatures (up to 300℃, such as apron conveyors used in the metallurgical industry for conveying high-temperature steel ingots), and are resistant to acids, alkalis, and wear, making them suitable for harsh working conditions (such as mining, chemical, and metallurgical industries).
Belt Conveyor:
• Flexible belts are sensitive to temperature;conventional rubber belts are suitable for temperatures between-10℃ and 80℃, and can age and crack outside this range;for high-temperature environments (such as drying lines), special materials (such as silicone belts, Teflon belts) are needed, which significantly increases costs and still cannot withstand extremely high temperatures.
Ⅲ. Summary of Application Scenarios
Conveyor Type | Core Application Scenarios | Typical Case Examples |
Slat conveyor | Large-sized/ heavy materials, high-temperature/ corrosive materials, steep incline conveying, harsh working conditions | Conveying ores in mines, conveying steel slag in metallurgy, conveying acid-base raw materials in chemical industry |
Belt Conveyor | Bulk/ powdery materials, lightweight materials, gentle conveying, low-noise/ low-maintenance requirements, ambient temperature and clean working conditions | Conveying grains in grain storage facilities, conveying coal in power plants, conveying packages in logistics sorting |
Ⅳ. Selection Recommendations
When to Prioritize Slat conveyors:
• When the material is large-sized (>50mm), heavy (single piece weighing>10kg), sharp, or high-temperature (>80℃).
• When the on-site space is limited and steep (>25°) or vertical conveying is required.
• When the working conditions are harsh (such as high dust levels, corrosive environments), and high equipment durability is required.
When to Prioritize Belt Conveyors:
• When the material is in bulk, granular, or powdery form (such as flour, cement), and there are no sharp impurities.
• When the conveying distance is long (belt conveyors can achieve continuous conveying over hundreds of meters, while slat conveyors, due to chain limitations, have higher costs for long distances) and the incline angle is small (<20°).
• When there are strict requirements for operating noise, maintenance costs, and energy consumption (such as in food processing and logistics warehousing).
As can be seen from the above comparison, the core of choosing between the two lies in "material characteristics” and "working condition requirements” —for rigid materials and harsh working conditions, slat conveyors are preferred, while for flexible materials and gentle, clean working conditions, belt conveyors are the better choice.
slat conveyor,Belt Conveyor,material characteristics,working condition requirements,conveyor for rigid materials,conveyor for harsh working condition
Previous page
Previous page
Get a Free Quote
We sincerely welcome you to write to us, call us to inquire about our business, visit us, inspect us, buy us and adopt us. You have any questions you can write to call, you can also leave a message on this site, the site administrator will do our best to provide you with the most efficient service.
HOT NEWS
Customer Service Hotline
Add：No. 8, Changjiang Road East, Lucheng Street, Yidu City, Hubei Province
Tel：+86-717-4904858 / 4820569
Mr. Zhou：+86-15871569828
Mr. Gong：+86-13508601368
Ms. Zou：+86-13872614986
© COPYRIGHT HUBEI YIDU YIYUN MEC.&ELEC. ENGINEERING CO.,LTD ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | Power by 300.cn
SAF Coolest v1.3.1.2 设置面板 GAGSD-ZGYF-JVZFE-ZVF
无数据提示
Sorry, the current section is being updated, so stay tuned!
You can view other columns or return to Home